Explaining The CAP Theorem Like Your 5
The easiest way to understand the CAP theorem and how databases work
What is the CAP Theorem?
Imagine you have three magical boxes, and each box gives you a special power:
1. Consistency (C): Every time you look inside this box, you see the same thing. It’s like a magic book where all your friends can write their stories, and everyone reads the same story, no matter when they see.
2. Availability (A): This box is always open and ready for you to look inside. You can check it anytime, and it will always show you something, even if it’s not the latest update.
3. Partition Tolerance (P): This box can work even when part of the system is broken or not talking to the other parts. It’s like having a phone that works even if some phone towers are down.
The CAP theorem says that when you're designing a distributed database system, you can only pick two of these three capabilities.
You can’t have all three at the same time. So, you have to make a choice based on what’s most important for the system you are designing.
Why is the CAP Theorem Important in System Design?
In the real world, systems often face challenges like network failures or heavy traffic, which can cause parts of the system to be temporarily unreachable.
Understanding the CAP theorem helps system designers make smart choices about how to handle these situations.
For example, if you are designing a system for a bank, you might want to prioritize Consistency and Partition Tolerance to ensure that all account balances are correct, even if some parts of the system go down.
On the other hand, if you are designing a social media platform, it is often recommended to prioritize Availability and Partition Tolerance to ensure that users can always post and see content, even if it’s not perfectly up-to-date.
In some database systems you can have Eventual Consistency, which offers the next best thing after strong consistency. One of the examples below (DynamoDB will touch on this idea further).
The CAP Theorem In Distributed Databases
Let’s take a look at two popular databases: DynamoDB and MongoDB, and see how they fit into the CAP theorem.
DynamoDB: AP (Availability and Partition Tolerance)
Amazon's DynamoDB is designed to be highly available and partition-tolerant. This means:
Availability: DynamoDB ensures that users can always read and write data, even if some servers are down. This is great for applications that need to be always up and running.
- Partition Tolerance: DynamoDB can handle network failures and still keep working. This makes it very reliable in distributed environments.
DynamoDB might sometimes show you slightly outdated data because it prioritizes being available and resilient to network issues.
This is fine for applications where getting some data quickly is more important than getting the latest data every single time, like in online shopping or gaming.
With eventual consistency, the older data does not remain for long and DynamoDB is usually quick to update it.
MongoDB: CP (Consistency and Partition Tolerance)
MongoDB, on the other hand, focuses on consistency and partition tolerance. This means:
- Consistency: MongoDB ensures that every user sees the same data, no matter which server they connect to. This is crucial for applications where accuracy is critical, like in banking or e-commerce transactions.
- Partition Tolerance: MongoDB can keep working even if some servers can’t communicate with each other. This ensures that the system remains operational during network issues.
MongoDB might sometimes be less available because it ensures that all users see the same, accurate data. This is important for applications where consistency is more important than always being available, like financial transactions or order processing apps. [1]
Conclusion
The CAP theorem is like a rulebook for designing distributed systems. It helps you understand the trade-offs between consistency, availability, and partition tolerance.
By knowing which of these qualities are most important for your application, you can choose the right database and design a system that meets your needs.
So when designing a database; assess your needs in terms of availability and consistency and you will then be able to make a better informed and accurate decision to build the best possible system.
👋 My name is Uriel Bitton and I’m committed to helping you master AWS, Cloud Computing, and Serverless development. ☁️
🚀 If you want to learn how to build enterprise-level, scalable, and resilient applications, follow me and subscribe.
🥰 You can also follow my journey on:
See you in the next one!